Muqarnas   (2019-)

Muqarnas - elaborate ornamental vaultings - are some of the earliest and most impressive examples of a rule-based architectural design. They combine architecture, mathematics, and art to form highly intricate and complex stalactite structures. The beauty of these abstract, non-figurative formations has fascinated people throughout history.

Today, advances in computational design and digital fabrication invite us to revisit these typologies. Can we generalize and formalize a constructive logic for muqarnas? Can the computer help us to explore new and unseen muqarna formations? In this project, the computer becomes a tool for search and exploration, a partner in our quest for the hitherto unseen. It allows us to create objects of exceptional breadth and depth: endless permutations of designs with a richness of detail that can once again evoke marvel, curiosity and bewilderment.

Historical Archetypes

Muqarnas date back to the 11th century Seljuk dynasty. They were initially structural elements of transition between the square floorplan of a building and the circular base of its dome. These structural transitions consisted of several stacked, overlapping horizontal layers. Over time, connections between the layers became increasingly articulated, and muqarnas came to be more and more sculptural. Gradually, a complex system of ornament emerged that was independent of any structural functionality.

Muqarnas developed into an archetypical form throughout the Islamic world, adorning interiors and portals of mosques, madrasas, shrines, and palaces. The saturation effect produced by their thousands of individual facets is said to evoke the star filled sky, while their vaulted form is sometimes associated with the cave in which prophet Mohammed's enlightenment took place.

Over the centuries, endless geometric variations of muqarnas were constructed - many with a remarkable ingenuity and visual complexity. The underlying constructive principle of these designs is identical: a step-wise transition between two geometries expressed as a sequence of individual tiers. These tiers can be depicted in a single ceiling plan as contour lines.

Despite their simple constructive logic, ceiling plans of historical muqarnas oftentimes contain complex geometrical patterns. These patterns can include nonperiodic tilings with multiple degrees of rotational symmetry. It is arguably the compositional combination of simple horizontal layers with these complex planar tilings that is the origin of muqarnas' appeal and has fascinated viewers throughout the centuries.

Algorithmic Composition

Can we formalize a simple yet open-ended algorithm that allows us to design intricate muqarnas? Can this algorithm help us to explore new and unseen muqarna formations?

The algorithmic approach in this project centers on the design of muqarna ceiling plans. It uses a selective subdivision algorithm to generate and successively refine these plans.

Given two countour lines representing the top and bottom planar outlines of a muqarna, this algorithm recursively subdivides the space between these lines into smaller and smaller tiles. To allow variations to take place - both between ceiling plan designs and locally within them, the algorithm's subdivision operation is applied selectively rather than uniformly. Topological and topographic features of each tile determine whether it is subdivided during a particular iteration of the process. In a subsequent step, contour lines are drawn between tiles of different tiers, and the ceiling plan is vertically extruded into a 3-dimensional geometry

This algorithm can be used to replicate historical muqarnas, but also to generate entirely new ones. The computer can produce millions of tiny tiles almost as easily as the hundreds contained in historical designs. At such a resolution, tiles and contour lines are not legible as individual polygons, but rather as continuous surfaces with potentially non-standard curvatures. In lieue of dozens of horizonal layers, the computer can quickly produce thousands. Thus layers are no longer visible as steps, and they require no further adornment through modules. Rather the a thousands of layers can appear as continuous concave and convex formations in their own right.

Ceiling plan produced through selective subdivision

Materialization:

Muqarna at Mori Art Museum

How can these algorithmic muqarnas be brought out of the computer into the real world? For their 2019-2020 Future and the Arts exhibition at Mori Art Museum in Tokyo, the curators commissioned a Muqarna Mutation: an algorithmically designed, robotically fabricated, full-scale muqarna to be installed in a central exhibition room.

This project uses the selective subdivision algorithm described above to create a muqarna that connects a massive pre-existing column at the center of an exhibition room to the room's ceiling. The algorithm generates hundreds of thousands of tiles set among dozens of tiers to create an extragavant ornamental transition from column to ceiling. The muqarna is materialized using 15,000 hollow, reflective aluminum tubes suspensed from a robotically milled tiered base.

Standing beneath the muqarna, visitors are struck by a mix of bewilderment and curiosity: a disorientating sensory overload partially obscures the underlying compositional logic. Patterns are readily discernible as one changes perspectives, only to disappear again amidst the endless reflections.

The basis of Muqarna Mutation is a massive, pre-existing 1.6m wide structural column situated at the center of one of Mori Museum's exhibition rooms. Rather than contructing a muqarna in the constrained space between the column and the room's walls, the column itself is used as the basis of the muqarna. The muqarna creates a transition between this column and the room's ceiling.

A selective subdivision algorithm uses the column's outline as well as the ceiling's contour to produce a muqarna plan with hundreds of individual tiers, and millions of tiny facets. The algorithm maximizes the countour lines to create a vast landscape with seemingly endless detail, alternating between stalactives and concave formations. This initial design is depicted in the concept development images.

To facilitate fabrication, the many thin tiers of the original plan are transposed into sixteen wider tiers, and the millions of facets are recombined into a pattern of 15,000 flat tiles. Squinches between tiles of different tiers are articulated as individual, hollow aluminum tubes.

Reflections and interferences between the shiny tubes create a saturation effect that mirrors the muqarna's historical predecessors. Patterns appear and disappear as one moves beneath it and changes perspectives.

The fabrication of the Muqarna Mutation's took place at the ROSO Coop laboratory of Feng Chia University, Taiwan, under the expertise of Yu-Ting Sheng and Shih-Yuan Wang.

The muqarna was partitioned into sixteen horizonal tiers, and these in turn were divided into 40 separate components to facilitate transport and assembly. Individual tiers were robotically milled out high-density EPS. In a second step, thousands of holes of different depths and diameters were robotically drilled into the tiers. Separately, a smooth plastic foil was laser-cut and attached to the tiers to improve the surface quality. To articulate the the tiles of the original design, 15,000 individual hollow aluminum tubes were inserted into the tiers and glued into place. Specific tubes were custom fabricated in order to minimize their weight.

The completed muqarna has a surface area of 24m2 and a height of 5 meters.

Fabrication Team



Lead:   Yu-Ting Sheng 盛郁庭 (Feng Chia University)
Shih-Yuan Wang 王識源 (National Chiao Tung University)
Meng Hao 孟浩 (RoboticPlus)

Structural support:   Chen-Tung Chen 陳建同 (YUMU)
Kuan-Fan Chen 陳冠帆 (FA.S Studio)

Fabrication Assistants:   Fei-Fan Sung 宋非凡
Che-Wei Lin 林哲蔚
Wei-Tse Hung 洪維澤
Yu-Hsuan Pang 龐宇軒
Chung-Chieh Cheng 鄭中杰
Yi-Heng Lu 陆亦恒
Nai-Wei Lai 賴乃葳
Chieh-I Liu 劉婕怡
Chang-Chin Lee 李長錦
Shih-Kai Fan 范士凱
Yu-Syuan Wei 魏雨萱
Ching-Yun Tseng 曾慶芸
Ying-Yu Chen 陳盈佑
Yu-Wei Cheng 程昱維
Qin-Fei Liu 劉沁霏
Yen Heng Cheng 鄭硯恆

   

Partners and Sponsors



• Graduate Institute of Architecture - National Chiao Tung University
• RoboticPlus 大界機器人
• Nan Pao Resins Chemical
• YUMU Manufacture and Research
• A.S. Studio 原型結構工程顧問有限公司

Muqarna Mutation is a commission by the Mori Art Museum, Tokyo, for its Future and the Arts exhibition. It premiered in November 2019.